Stop Gun Deaths
December 8, 2009

Exploding the Gun Lobby’s Deadly Myths That Paralyze American Gun Policy — FSA Book Interview With Dennis Henigan

(Use this link to purchase your copy today from Amazon.com and support the Freedom States Alliance. When shopping online at Amazon.com, up to 5% will be donated back to our efforts to save lives from gun violence).

Freedom States Alliance communications director, Scott Vogel, interviewed Dennis Henigan, author of a vitally important and new book, "Lethal Logic: Exploding the Myths That Paralyze American Gun Policy."

Mr. Henigan is the vice president for law and policy at the Brady Center to Prevent Gun Violence and founder of its Legal Action Project. For twenty years, he has been a leading advocate for stronger gun laws.

FREEDOM STATES ALLIANCE INTERVIEW

FSA: The gun lobby has been able to advance its irresponsible agenda, not just through money and political power – two very important factors – but through their overly simplistic sound bites. Would you say that the gun lobby's messaging strategy is their best weapon?

Dennis Henigan: Yes, it's a critical factor. The vast majority of the American people support stronger gun laws and yet our political system seems at a stalemate on the issue. I have struggled with this anomaly for the twenty years that I’ve been involved with the gun violence prevention issue.

There is an intensity gap in terms of advocacy on both sides of this issue. The gun lobby has a cadre of people who are intensely devoted to their cause and will be very politically active in influencing legislators, especially during elections. Yet the vast majority of the people who favor stronger gun laws don’t seem to do so with the same kind of intensity. One of the fundamental problems is that the gun lobby has been able to dominate the discourse with these very simple messages that resonate on some level with people who need to be persuaded on the issue.

For example, the phrase “guns don’t kill people, people kill people.” That line, like all these bumper-sticker slogans, is a cleverly disguised fallacy. But it resonates with a lot of people who think that the real problem of violence is not a gun problem but a problem of violent people. We see this effect when there is a mass shooting such as the Columbine tragedy. During that high-profile tragedy a great deal of public attention immediately focused on the shooters, the problem of disaffected youth, bad parenting, the influence of violent video games, bullying in school, etc.

But the discussion missed the more obvious point that the tragedy at Columbine happened in the way it did because those two disaffected teenagers had access to guns. The problem was not as much two deeply alienated teenagers. The problem was their access to the instruments of killing.

That whole national dialogue that occurred after Columbine was an illustration of this way of thinking about gun violence that is captured in the phrase “guns don’t kill people; people kill people.”

FSA: A big part of the gun lobby's success, if you call it that, is cynically embedding fear in its messages. They promote fear on multiple levels – fear of the government, President Obama, the United Nations, and obviously gun control itself. But they also use fear on a very localized level – the fear of the common criminal and not being able to protect yourself. I keep thinking that the “fear card” has been overplayed but it clearly works with the radical elements of the gun lobby. Clearly selling fear works to their advantage.

Henigan: I think advocates of stronger gun laws need to constantly talk about the seriousness of the gun violence problem at every level. Many Americans intellectually support stronger gun laws. They will tell a pollster that they support such reforms as universal background checks on gun sales for example. But they are not yet convinced that gun violence is a specific threat to them and their family or that, even if it is a threat, there are some doubts that stronger gun laws will make a real difference in their lives. Nonetheless, there is no question that stronger gun laws would make our communities safer and more secure.

There is no question that we are all constantly at grave risk from gun violence of various forms, whether we live in the inner city, whether we live in the suburbs or rural areas. There’s no question that the risk is there. But we have to go further and be able to convince the American people that sensible gun laws will in fact make a difference.

And that brings to bear one of the gun lobby’s other prominent bumper stickers, which is “When guns are outlawed, only outlaws will have guns.” That bumper sticker is used to express skepticism about whether gun control laws really have an effect on access to guns by dangerous people. Although it is easily demonstrable that gun laws have saved lives and stronger laws will save even more lives, there still exists a troubling degree of skepticism on the part of the public about whether that’s true. And it’s essential that we overcome that.

FSA: What’s the origin of some of the gun lobby's bumper-sticker messages? Surely they were tested in focus groups.

Henigan: There are some messages that are of very recent origin, and I do track the history of, for example, the message that we “don’t need new gun laws, we just need to enforce the laws we have now.” That message was very clearly created out of whole cloth by the NRA for a specific purpose, and that was to discredit the Clinton administration’s efforts to advance a gun control agenda. I go in great detail in the book on how the gun lobby used that phrase against the Clinton administration. Of course it's utter hypocrisy for the gun lobby to argue for stronger enforcement of laws that they have long opposed, and then doing everything they can to change the laws so to weaken enforcement.

That message was probably the subject of extensive focus group testing, and it was trotted out for a specific purpose to deflate any effort to pass stronger federal gun laws. It is all the more troubling when we see recent statements by House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and President Barack Obama. When asked about proposals to ban assault weapons, they have both invoked the notion that we ought to concentrate on enforcing the laws we have.

So it’s very troubling to hear these national leaders who have been prominent advocates of stronger gun laws for their entire careers actually channeling the NRA’s rhetoric in this way.

To be clear, my book is not a communications treatise, and I'm not analyzing the gun violence prevention movement's messaging strategy. But it’s undeniable that the gun lobby’s success can in large part be traced to its effective use of these simple bumper-sticker slogans.

I know that many gun violence prevention advocates are frustrated by our inability to come with counter-bumper stickers. But it’s not clear to me that that’s the solution. I do think it is absolutely critical that these cleverly disguised fallacies that the gun lobby has been getting away with be exposed and be completely routed. That is my intention in the book, to give gun control advocates and policymakers many of the tools needed to deconstruct and destroy these very harmful messages.

FSA: In addition to their use of rhetoric, don't you think that there is an inherent advantage to the gun lobby and industry – just like all special interests – that can say, essentially, “no” to everything. Systemic policy changes threaten the status quo. Being any kind of an advocate, especially those challenging one of the most powerful lobbies in Washington such as the NRA, have a harder time making the case for change versus those that always deflect and deflate the problem. Advocates have a steeper hill to climb.

Read on...

More: Legislation, NRA, Concealed Carry, Politics, Activism, Gun Control, Brady Campaign, Freedom States Alliance

November 6, 2009

Brady Campaign: Fort Hood Killer Reportedly Chose “Cop Killer” Handgun

More: America's Shooting Gallery, Police, Texas, Armed Citizens, Shootings, Assault weapons, Gun Manufacturers, Police Shot, Brady Campaign

August 7, 2009

Three Times, Same Wisconsin Gun Dealer Has Helped Supply Killers — CCW Permit George Sodini Latest Rampage Shooter To Purchase High-Capacity Ammunition Magazines From Eric Thompson’s Online Gun Store

More: Pennsylvania, Culture of Violence, Concealed Carry, Wisconsin, Armed Citizens, Assault weapons, VA Tech, Murder Suicide, Brady Campaign, Freedom States Alliance

July 14, 2009

National Gun Violence Prevention Groups Express Outrage That in Wake of Shootings, U.S. Senate is Poised to Consider Legislation to Dramatically Weaken State Concealed Handgun Laws

More: Legislation, NRA, Culture of Violence, Crime, Concealed Carry, Illegal Guns, Armed Citizens, VPC, Gun Control, Gun Trafficking, Brady Campaign, Freedom States Alliance, Local Gun Laws

July 8, 2009

From Coast To Coast, State Lawmakers Categorically Reject Forcing Guns Onto College Campuses

More: Legislation, Concealed Carry, Law Makers, Armed Citizens, School Shootings, Background Checks, gun protests, Activism, VA Tech, Gun Show Loophole, Brady Campaign, Freedom States Alliance

June 2, 2009

Gun Lobby Fails To Force Hidden and Loaded Guns On College Campuses In Texas As Legislative Session Ends

More: Legislation, Culture of Violence, Texas, Concealed Carry, Armed Citizens, Students, VA Tech, Brady Campaign, Guns On Campus

May 9, 2009

MUST READ: The Deadly Myth of Gun Control in Electoral Politics

More: Legislation, NRA, Assault weapons, Activism, Gun Control, elections, Brady Campaign, Obama

April 21, 2009

Senators Join Shooting Victims and Family Members To Push For Closing the Gun Show Loophole

More: Legislation, Gun Sales, NRA, Politics, Illegal Guns, Background Checks, Gun dealers, Gun culture, VA Tech, Gun Trafficking, Gun Show Loophole, Brady Campaign

March 30, 2009

Illinois: Advocates Protest Rep. Eddie Washington’s Office For Opposing Bill To Require Background Checks On All Deadly Handgun Sales — Washington Received $3,000 In Donations From Union Also Headed By Gun Lobbyist

More: Legislation, NRA, Illinois, Politics, Background Checks, Brady Campaign

March 13, 2009

Federal Appeals Court Upholds Lower Court: No Guns At Atlanta Hartsfield Airport

More: Georgia, Concealed Carry, Courts, Armed Citizens, Activism, Brady Campaign

January 19, 2009

In Landmark Ruling, Indiana’s State Supreme Court Says Gary’s Lawsuit Against the Gun Industry Can Proceed To Trial

More: Indiana, Illegal Guns, Guns, Liability, Brady Campaign

December 23, 2008

BuzzFlash.com Interview With Freedom States Alliance: Americans’ Attitudes About Guns Are Changing

More: Concealed Carry, .50 caliber, District of Columbia, Politics, symbols, Assault weapons, Background Checks, Activism, elections, handgun bans, Supreme Court, National Parks, Brady Campaign, Freedom States Alliance

December 15, 2008

Gun Clubs Desperately Spinning Their Safety Record After Boy’s Uzi Death

More: kids & guns, Liability, machine guns, New England, Brady Campaign, Associated Press

December 2, 2008

The Gun Lobby’s Major Defeat: Questions Abound If the NRA’s Extremist Agenda Is Relevant Anymore

More: Legislation, NRA, Politics, elections, Brady Campaign, Obama

Archives
Every article on the site, listed by month.
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
Hot Shots
Our most popular articles, based on pageviews, linkage, and feedback.

»When it Comes to .50 Caliber Terror, Bigger is Badder

»Welcome to Florida! Wish You Weren't Shot!

».50 Caliber Ad Causes Trouble in California

».50 Caliber Rifles Target US Nuclear Plants

»Terrorist Indictment Brings Calls for .50 Caliber Rifle Ban